Are premium own brands actually worth the price?
Premium own brands like Coles Finest and Woolworths Gold are cheaper than branded products but pricier than standard home brand. Are they worth it?
Coles Finest and Woolworths Gold represent a middle tier between budget home brand and premium branded products. Both tiers are growing. Coles Finest revenue grew 20.4 percent in FY24. But if you are shopping on a tight budget, is paying 15-30 percent more for premium own brand worth it, or should you stick with standard home brand?
Pinch tracks prices on both tiers across 52 weeks, helping you decide which products justify the premium step and which do not.
The three-tier own brand system
Both major retailers now use a three-tier strategy:
- Budget tier: Coles Brand, Woolworths Home Brand. Cheapest, minimal packaging, basic ingredients.
- Mid tier (premium own brand): Coles Finest, Woolworths Gold. Better ingredients, more sophisticated flavours, premium packaging.
- Premium tier: Branded products (Nestle, Kraft, Kelloggs, etc.). Highest price, brand recognition, advertising spend built into cost.
The gap between budget and premium own brand is typically 15-30 percent. The gap between premium own brand and branded is typically 20-40 percent. The question: does that 15-30 percent premium buy you meaningful quality improvement?
Where premium own brand makes sense
Premium own brands are worth the extra cost for these categories:
- Chocolate and biscuits: Coles Finest and Woolworths Gold versions taste noticeably better than budget, at half the price of branded equivalents. Many shoppers cannot taste the difference from premium brands.
- Yoghurt and dairy products: Premium own brand yoghurt has better texture and more fruit than budget. Still 30-40 percent cheaper than branded.
- Breakfast cereals: Premium own brand has better ingredients (more whole grain, less sugar) than budget. Closer to premium brands in nutrition but significantly cheaper.
- Sauces and condiments: Taste varies more by recipe than brand. Premium own brand performs well here.
- Cheese and deli items: Premium own brand quality is noticeable, especially if you eat it regularly. Budget cheese is thinner and less flavourful.
Where standard home brand performs just as well
Save your premium own brand budget for items where quality is less important:
- Tinned vegetables and beans: Coles Brand tinned tomatoes are chemically identical to Coles Finest. No taste difference.
- Rice, pasta, flour, and staples: These are commodities. Specification-based, not brand-based. Budget is fine.
- Cleaning products and paper goods: Paper towel is paper towel. Budget performs the same.
- Milk and butter: No meaningful quality difference between budget and premium own brand. Both use the same suppliers.
- Oil and basic ingredients: Standard home brand oil is the same as premium own brand oil.
The hybrid approach: save on average household
For a household with a tight grocery budget, this strategy maximizes value:
- Buy standard home brand for staples and commodities (rice, pasta, tinned goods, milk, oil, sugar, flour)
- Buy premium own brand for items you eat often and taste regularly (cheese, biscuits, yoghurt, breakfast cereal, chocolate)
- Avoid branded products entirely unless it is a special occasion or you have strong personal preference
This hybrid approach typically costs 10-15 percent more than budget own brand everywhere, but delivers better quality on items that matter. For a household spending $200 per week on groceries, that extra 10-15 percent means an additional $20-30 per week. You get noticeably better taste and quality on items you eat regularly, while maintaining most of the savings of switching to own brand.
When to skip premium own brand entirely
If your household budget is genuinely tight ($150-180 per week), prioritize these choices:
- Buy standard home brand across all categories
- When you have spare budget ($5-10 per week), spend it on premium own brand eggs, cheese, or yoghurt because you eat them frequently
- Use Pinch to track weekly specials and stock up on premium own brand when on sale (often 10-20 percent discount)
- Save branded products for genuine special occasions
Switching from branded to standard home brand saves you 20-35 percent immediately. That is $35-70 per week. The question of whether to add premium own brand on top is secondary. If you cannot afford the step up, you are not losing anything meaningful.
Track prices on both tiers
Pinch shows you real prices across budget home brand, premium own brand, and branded products. See exactly where paying the premium makes sense for your household.
Download Pinch (free on iOS, Android coming soon). No ads. No data selling.